Embraer Eyes WTO Challenge To Bombardier State Funding

May 16, 2016

Embraer may challenge the state funding received by Canadian rival Bombardier at the WTO, a senior executive has said.

Paulo Cesar Silva, the head of Embraer's commercial aviation unit, told Reuters that government financing has given Bombardier an unfair advantage in sales campaigns where its new CSeries is up against Embraer's E-Jets.

"The WTO is an alternative" to resolve the potential trade dispute, Silva said. "Another channel could be government-to-government talks. That might be the best way to avoid a dispute."

Embraer contacted the Brazilian government, but still needs details of Bombardier's financing arrangements before taking action, Silva added.

Brazil and Canada have locked horns repeatedly at the WTO over the past two decades regarding state support for Embraer and Bombardier.

Bombardier secured USD$1 billion for its C Series aircraft from the Quebec government last year and has asked Canada's federal government to match the investment.

Embraer's concerns about the funding boiled over last month when Bombardier won an aggressive bid for 75 aircraft for US carrier Delta Air Lines.

Several industry sources have pegged the discount close to two-thirds off the nominal CS100 list price of USD$71.8 million, but people close to Bombardier have denied this.

"Given the support, Bombardier has been very aggressive, to the point of offering planes at prices below their production costs. That's what the numbers show," Silva said.

"It causes a major distortion in the market. We're not competing with a private enterprise any more. We're competing with the government," he said. "And the one footing the bill is the Canadian taxpayer."

"Our transactions are all in full compliance with WTO rules," Bombardier spokeswoman Marianella de la Barrera said. "Those comments (from Embraer) are not based on facts. The (Delta) selection was based on the aircraft's proven performance."

De la Barrera added that while Bombardier was given a commitment from the Quebec government, the company has not received any cash from the province because the deal has not yet been finally agreed.

(Reuters)