American Air's Creditors Want To Talk Merger
Some American Airlines unsecured creditors increasingly feel the bankrupt airline should explore a deal with US Airways or another carrier, after hearing parent company AMR's plan to remain independent, people familiar with the situation said.
Members of the unsecured creditors committee -- which includes banks representing bondholders, labour, vendors and the US pension protection agency -- are concerned about the third-largest US carrier's prospect of staying competitive as a stand-alone airline after sitting out the latest round of mergers.
They want AMR management to explore other options that may lead to a better recovery of their claims, including a potential combination with another carrier, according to people who requested anonymity because they were not authorised to speak publicly on the matter.
US Airways has said it is considering an eventual bid for its larger rival.
While different creditors have different economic interests at stake, the sources said consensus is growing at the committee on the need to look at other alternatives.
Even unions, which traditionally do not like mergers because they come with job cuts, want to explore how a deal with a rival carrier would affect their members even though they may not necessarily favour it, the sources said. AMR's three largest unions -- pilots, flight attendants and ground workers -- all have seats on the creditors committee.
For now, AMR management has the exclusive right to submit its own plan to reorganise under bankruptcy court protection, and the airline has said it wants to emerge as a stand-alone company.
But creditors could petition the bankruptcy judge to terminate that right to make way for competing plans, and the committee would ultimately also need to sign off on any reorganisation plan.
There is no offer on the table currently, and it remains to be seen if any merger proposal by US Airways or anyone else will require concessions less painful to creditors than what is sought by AMR management.
But creditors' frustration in the ongoing restructuring talks and their interest in exploring alternatives could provide the opening for a potential suitor to step in.
AMR, however, has shown no interest in a merger with US Airways or anyone else.
“AMR will continue to pursue the objectives of Chapter 11 to restructure and build a new, better, more efficient and profitable airline in the best interests of all of its economic stakeholders, passengers and the public,” the company told reporters.
Industry insiders say high anti-trust hurdles make Delta an unlikely buyer for AMR. They also question how US Airways would benefit American outside of the East Coast, where US Airways has a particularly strong route network.
American already has plenty of cash, a strong domestic route network and service to Europe and Asia as well as related oneworld alliance partners in London and Tokyo. Labour troubles at US Airways dating to its 2005 merger with America West are also a red flag for heavily unionised American.
NO DIRECT TALKS
The creditors committee has not had any direct formal talks with US Airways or any other potential merger partner, the sources said.
Aside from unions, the committee includes the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC), the government agency that protects underfunded pension plans; Boeing, Hewlett Packard; and the banks acting for AMR bondholders -- Wilmington Trust, Bank of New York Mellon and Manufacturers & Traders Trust.
Representatives for all these parties declined to comment.
AMR's pilots' union, the Allied Pilots Association, would not comment on the prospect of a specific merger scenario. A spokesman for the group, Gregg Overman, said the union would review any proposal if "something comes up" and "we'll evaluate it on the merits."
AMR's flight attendants also declined to comment. But a source familiar with the group's thinking said that while the union prefers to see the airline "grow and succeed" as a stand-alone company, it has so far not seen a business plan from management that would allow that to happen.
The flight attendants' union believes a merger with US Airways is "dicey at best" due to the fact that it has yet to fully integrate its labour groups after its 2005 merger with America West Airlines.
The Transport Workers Union of America, which represents many ground-workers at American, is currently focused on examining AMR's business plan released last week and will fully assess it before considering other proposals, the union said in a statement.
AMR filed for Chapter 11 on November 29, citing a need to trim uncompetitive labour costs. The company told employees last week that it aims to cut expenses by USD$2 billion a year, slash about 13,000 jobs and terminate pensions. AMR also intends to generate USD$1 billion per year in new revenue.
Delta Air Lines has hired advisors to explore its merger prospects with AMR, which would bring the number two and number three US carriers together. US Airways is the fifth largest US airline.
AMR has the right to submit a reorganisation plan without outside interference for 120 days after its bankruptcy filing. The judge can extend that right for up to 18 months.
The exclusive period makes it difficult for an unwanted suitor to attempt a merger unless the creditors back such a move.
US Airways has had a similar experience in the past. In January 2007 the airline withdrew its USD$9.75 billion hostile takeover bid for Delta, which was bankrupt then, after the creditors committee refused to support the move. Delta management convinced the panel the carrier would be stronger if it emerged from bankruptcy independent.
Among the big carrier bankruptcies of the last ten years, only US Airways came out of Chapter 11 with a merger, and that was with smaller America West. Delta and Northwest aligned their restructurings and merged in 2008 only after each stepped out of bankruptcy.